Nagi Umino turns down his childhood friend Ai Mochizuki when she returns to Japan and announces that she intends to marry him. But his refusal does not discourage her: Ai remains determined to have Nagi to herself, adding another complication to his already crowded romantic life.
Nagi and his fiancée, Erika Amano, were swapped at birth and now live together. Their household also includes his sister, Sachi, and his crush, Hiro Segawa. Though arguments are frequent, the four have begun adjusting to their unusual situation. Ai's arrival unsettles that emerging routine. With four girls around him, each with her own feelings about him, Nagi has to sort out what he wants and decide how to move forward.