WWF No Mercy lets players create their own wrestling events and compete for titles unlocked through Championship mode. Each of its seven WWF championships has a separate story, which can be replayed to defend a title. Completing a story unlocks that championship in Exhibition mode, where players can win and defend it.
Up to four players can compete in modes that include cage and ladder contests and pay-per-view events. Some matches take place outside the ring, across four backstage locations.