Still Life 2 follows two playable heroines on opposite sides of the same case: Victoria McPherson investigates the killer, while Paloma Hernandez must survive as the victim. Switching characters changes both the viewpoint and the type of play.
Victoria's investigation takes her to Maine in fall 2008 after Ellen Dunnigan's body is discovered. The killer's methods and a video sent to police and the press point to the East Coast Torturer, but the body has been carefully washed, leaving the autopsy without clues.