Mario Super Sluggers combines baseball matches with a single-player Challenge mode set in Baseball Kingdom. Starting as Mario, players explore areas associated with different captains and complete objectives to recruit teammates for games against Bowser Jr. and Bowser. Captains have special abilities for finding teammates and coins, which buy items to help during the quest or those matches.
Exhibition mode lets players set the number of innings and enable or disable captains’ star swings and pitches, as well as items thrown at fielders. In Toy Field, players take turns batting for points. Holding the ball after a set interval earns the next turn, but fielders can attack one another to steal it. The batter can also throw items to make fielders drop the ball and gain another turn.