Alongside standard tennis, Mario Power Tennis includes variants with different scoring rules and ways to interfere with opponents. In Ring Shot, players hit the ball through rings of varying sizes, with harder shots worth more points. Those points are awarded when the player wins the point under standard tennis rules; reaching or exceeding a set score wins the match. Item Battle lets characters use Mario-themed items to disrupt each other's play.
Court selection also changes the matches. The game includes standard tennis surfaces and themed “Gimmick” courts with obstacles that affect play. On the Luigi's Mansion court, for example, contact with ghosts hinders a character's movement.