Dungeon exploration in Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals involves solving puzzles with items and accessories. Enemies move visibly through dungeons rather than appearing in random encounters, while battles use a turn-based system. Summoned allies called Capsule Monsters can participate in combat and evolve by consuming weapons, armour or special fruits.
Set ninety-nine years before Lufia & the Fortress of Doom, the story explores the origins of the Sinistrals, a group of super-humans. An encounter with the mysterious Iris begins a quest to gather heroes and prevent the Sinistrals from destroying the world.