A pizza delivery sets the central trouble in motion in LEGO Island: Pepper inadvertently frees the jailed Brickster and must recapture him before he disassembles the entire island.
The game uses a first-person perspective and a nonlinear structure, with missions ranging from delivering pizzas to racing jet skis and returning the Brickster to jail. Several characters are playable, each with distinct abilities that can help during the game.