The Origami Killer connects the otherwise separate lives of four playable characters in Heavy Rain: Ethan Mars, a father and the main protagonist; private investigator Scott Shelby; FBI agent Norman Jayden; and photojournalist Madison Paige. They do not know one another at the outset, but each has an interest in the killer.
The story deals with adult themes and moral choices. Its characters have different backgrounds, motivations and skills, and the player's decisions influence subsequent events.