A prison boxing match opens Fight Night Champion before the story moves back four years to Andre Bishop's early professional career. Working with trainer Gus Carisi, Bishop attracts the attention of promoter DL McQueen. Bishop's refusal to sign with McQueen leads to him being framed for assault and imprisoned.
The story spans Bishop's rise through professional boxing, fights behind bars and an attempt to rebuild his career as a heavyweight. His brother Raymond also becomes a professional fighter, but signs with the promoter responsible for Andre's imprisonment.