In Costume Quest, choosing between twins Wren and Reynold determines who sets out to rescue the other. The chosen twin wears a robot costume; their sibling dresses as candy corn and is kidnapped by monsters who mistake them for the real thing. The rescue mission begins on Halloween night in Auburn Pines.
Players lead a group of young friends door-to-door, gathering candy, points, cards, battle stamps and quests. During combat, their homemade costumes transform them into larger-than-life versions of their disguises, each with its own superpowers for fighting monsters.