Collapsing blocks, sticky walls, bouncy volcanic rocks and spikes shape the levels in BattleBlock Theater. Players run, jump and punch through these courses, avoiding water and dangerous creatures. Gems found during challenges can be spent to unlock other imprisoned crew members as playable characters.
The prisoner is part of the shipwrecked S.S. Friendship crew, captured by cats who force them to perform deadly games in a dilapidated theater. Their friend Hatty Hattington appears to lead the captors after being fitted with a mysterious glowing top hat. A narrator tells the story, with most cutscenes presented in a stick-puppet style.