Koyomi Araragi's girlfriend and his sister have a swindler in common. Deishuu Kaiki once conned Hitagi Senjougahara's family, and now Karen Araragi has crossed him. Hitagi resorts to kidnapping Koyomi to keep him out of Kaiki's reach, but Karen's urgent plea draws him into the conflict.
Having recently survived a vampire attack, Koyomi is already familiar with supernatural troubles. Now his other sister, Tsukihi, has problems of her own, and two mysterious women enter their lives as unsettling truths about the family emerge.