Nadeko Sengoku wants to become a professional manga artist, but for now the middle school student keeps to her room rather than returning to school. Still recovering from recent supernatural encounters, she devotes her time to drawing. Yotsugi Ononoki offers her a way to develop her skills faster: create four copies of herself, each embodying a different part of her personality.
Yotsugi has taken on the role of local occult expert since Koyomi Araragi left for university. Formerly a human corpse and now a living doll, she stays at his home to watch over his sister Tsukihi, who has a mystical secret of her own. With new curses and problems troubling Araragi's friends, Yotsugi also helps others around town.
Her advice to Nadeko backfires when the copies refuse to cooperate and escape. Nadeko must track down the four unruly versions of herself while confronting the divisions within her own identity.